Customer Testimonials
Laura D.
Elizabeth M.
Elizabeth M.
Custom design sugar cookies and cake pops means your event will be unique with unforgettable treats. I have ordered custom sugar cookies for larger gatherings and for individual gift bags. Each item is individually wrapped which makes it great for gift gifting and hygienically serving larger groups. The cake pops are always prepared perfectly and treat for the recipient. I decorated my Valentine's dinner table with cookies and bouquets of cake pops. It is the perfect edible decor which minimizes clean up and my guests were thrilled with the confections. All is prepared and delivered with joy and happiness in every bite. I highly recommend CayPop's to create custom and signature items for your event, large or small.
Elizabeth M.
Elizabeth M.
Elizabeth M.
I can’t say enough great things about CayPops!!! Their cookies are absolutely delicious—perfectly baked, fresh, and full of flavor. You can tell they use high-quality ingredients and put so much care into every batch. On top of that, their customer service is outstanding! They are friendly, responsive, and truly go above and beyond to make sure every order is perfect. Whether you need a special order for an event or just a sweet treat for yourself, this CayPops is your to go. Highly recommend!
Allison C.
Elizabeth M.
Allison C.
“Caylyn is a very talented young lady. She creates the most amazing baked treats. Iced cutout cookies, cake pops and cinnamon roll cookies to name a few. They all taste amazing and are custom made to order. We have ordered custom sports team treats as well as custom holiday themed treats. She is a delight to work with, her creativity is amazing and everything is super yummy. I give Caylyn and her business 5++++ stars.”
Laura M.
Haylee C.
Allison C.
“I’m never disappointed when I order from CayPops! The baked goods are delicious. The decorating is top notch. She never fails to deliver when I ask for custom items. And the customer service experience is excellent! I have ordered for personal events (birthday parties, Valentine’s Day treats or to satisfy a Tuesday cookie craving) and I have ordered for professional gifting for clients. Each and every time the quality is exceptional and everyone who tastes CayPops goodies is happier!!"
Erin R.
Haylee C.
Haylee C.
“There are many adjectives that come to mind when I think of Caylyn and the incredible business she has created, but top of the list are: delightful, capable, professional, energetic, creative and accessible. She has been so easy to work with and we have LOVED the desserts we have ordered from her on MANY occasions. I would HIGHLY recommend CayPops to anyone looking for a tasty treat!”
Haylee C.
Haylee C.
Haylee C.
“Caylyn is so extremely talented and professional with her products. She's so devoted and puts her whole heart in every treat that she makes. She really amazes me! Her packaging is so cute, the treats are always amazing no matter what, and she's so easy/flexible to work with for pick up or delivery. Would definitely recommend CayPops to anyone!”
Melanie F.
Melanie F.
Melanie F.
Cay Pops is the best for any cookie/cake pop needs! Every single event I throw I always have Cay Pops create a customized dessert option and there's never any left over. Not only are they delicious but she always nails the theme! They're always very accommodating and the prices are very fair. 100/10 recommend! Cannot wait to see what she creates next!
Angie M.
Melanie F.
Melanie F.
“I ordered a caramel brownie today from CayPops...and let me just say a couple of things...1st...I'm not a brownie fan...but I did have her buttercream sugar cookies are they were amazing!!! So...I thought let's just see, AND I WAS BLOWN AWAY ON HOW OUT OF THIS WORLD THAT BROWNIE WAS! If you haven't ordered from CayPops, what are you waiting on? Now I am a brownie fan, but only from CayPops!!!"
Leslie W.
Melanie F.
Leslie W.
“Caylyn makes the most delicious cookies and cake pops. Her sweet treats are gorgeous, fresh, soft, and mouth watering. Not to mention, her presentation and packaging is beautiful and professional. I would recommend Caylyn for any and all of your dessert needs."
Gary R.
Kenzie P.
Leslie W.
“Caylyn, I wanted to let you know that the Valentine heart brownie was delicious! Everyone enjoyed the flavor and your decorating skills! You are now my family's go to baker for all of our pastry needs! Thank you and good luck in your business adventure."
Kenzie P.
Kenzie P.
Kenzie P.
“I absolutely love CayPops Bakery! Every item made has had so much time and effort put into it. I’ve never had something that I didn’t love from CayPops. 11/10 would recommend!”
Molly F.
Kenzie P.
Kenzie P.
“Do yourself a favor and get yourself some cinnamon roll cookies from CayPops! Henry took one bite and said "best cookie of my life!" and this is a kid that loves and has had a lot of cookies!"
Melanie F.
Stephanie G.
Melanie F.
Cay Pops is the best for any cookie/cake pop needs! Every single event I throw I always have Cay Pops create a customized dessert option and there's never any left over. Not only are they delicious but she always nails the theme! They're always very accommodating and the prices are very fair. 100/10 recommend! Cannot wait to see what she creates next!
Shannon T.
Stephanie G.
Melanie F.
These were the most amazing cookies for my daughter’s bridal shower. We wanted just a touch of the “Friends” theme for the shower because my daughter has always loved it the show. The cookies were perfect and tasted delicious! Everyone loved them! Highly recommend CayPops!! They even sent a thank you cookie for placing an order!
Stephanie G.
Stephanie G.
Stephanie G.
I ordered cupcakes and mini-sugar cookies for a bridal shower. I got 4 different flavors of cupcakes, and they were all amazing! The icing was also very delicious! The owner is very friendly and easy to work with. I would recommend CayPops to everyone needing beautiful desserts.
Shannan F.
Shannan F.
Stephanie G.
Caypops is my favorite place to order treats. Caylyn is not only a talented baker, but she is the sweetest as well. My family has loved every confection that we have tried! Not only does everything taste delicious, it’s all beautiful as well!
Kim H.
Shannan F.
Amber E.
“Your Valentine's sugar cookies were marvelous! Our son, daughter-in-law and granddaughter loved them! And I sure enjoyed the one I ate! Will be ordering more from CayPops in the future! Thanks!"
Amber E.
Shannan F.
Amber E.
“CayPops are amazing! They not only taste great but are beautifully decorated! She is professional and efficient with filling orders. I was in a bind and she happily made a last minute order work!"
Carrie D.
Carrie D.
Carrie D.
Every time I have ordered from CayPops they have been delivered on time, freshly made, and absolutely delicious!!! She does an absolutely amazing job
Sue W.
Carrie D.
Carrie D.
“Your CayPops were AMAZING!! I shared them with my bible study ladies and had a couple left over to share with my husband. Mike and I really liked them as did the ladies! So moist and chocolatey."
Laurie M.
Carrie D.
Laurie M.
“The best chocolate chip cookies my family has ever had - and they are pretty tough critics! Keep up the great work Caylyn!"