CayPops
  • Home
  • Locations
    • Columbus, IN
    • Bowling Green, KY
  • Reviews
  • Join our Bakers Network!
  • More
    • Home
    • Locations
      • Columbus, IN
      • Bowling Green, KY
    • Reviews
    • Join our Bakers Network!
CayPops
  • Home
  • Locations
    • Columbus, IN
    • Bowling Green, KY
  • Reviews
  • Join our Bakers Network!

Serving joy & happiness in every bite!

menu

Serving Columbus, IN

Meet Caylyn Pruitt!

Caylyn is the CEO and founder of CayPops Bakery LLC. She got hooked on baking during the pandemic through watching "Kids Baking Championship" and several tutorials. Caylyn started her business when she was just 15 years old and has loved her entrepreneurial journey! She is currently furthering her education at Ivy Tech, while continuing to grow the business. Caylyn loves the creativity and flexibility that baking and entrepreneurship provides. Get your custom CayPops and cookies today! 

Menu

Classic CayPops

$35/dzn

- chocolate

- vanilla

- cookies & cream

- red velvet

- lemon

- strawberry

Custom CayPops

$40-45/dzn

- chocolate

- vanilla

- cookies & cream

- red velvet

- lemon

- strawberry

Caysicles

$45/dzn

- chocolate

- vanilla

- cookies & cream

- red velvet

- lemon

- strawberry

Custom Sugar Cookies

$45/dzn

Buttercream Sugar Cookies

$45/dzn

Mini Buttercream Sugar Cookies

$12/dzn

Cupcakes

$25/dzn

- chocolate

- vanilla

- cookies & cream

- red velvet

- lemon

- strawberry

Caramel Brownie, (9")

$20

Chocolate Chip Cookies

$12/dzn

Snickerdoodles

$12/dzn

Oatmeal Raisin

$20/dzn

Cinnamon Roll Cookies

$20/dzn

Chocolate Chip Pumpkin Bread

$12/3

Chocolate Chip Banana Bread

$12/3

Chocolate Pecan Pie (9")

$25

GLUTEN FREE

GF CayPops

$45/dzn

- Chocolate

- Vanilla

GF Standard Cupcakes

$35/dzn

- Chocolate

- Vanilla

GF Specialty Cupcakes

$40/dzn

- Cookies & Cream

- Mint Chocolate

- Chocolate Peanut Butter

GF Caramel Brownie (9")

$30
ORDER

Copyright © 2025 CayPops - All Rights Reserved.

Powered by